Euthanasia – a Greek term literally means ‘good death’. Like ‘gay’ it is a right word depicting a wrong notion. In ‘The Euthanasia Debate’, NM Harris provides with a definition of the term given by a Select Committee on Medical Ethics of House of Lords (Britain) which says that euthanasia is “a deliberate intervention undertaken with the express intention of ending a life, to relieve intractable suffering”.
On the basis of the varying consent of the patient, euthanasia has been classified as voluntary, non-voluntary and involuntary. Euthanasia conducted with the consent of the patient is termed ‘voluntary euthanasia’. Euthanasia conducted
where the consent of the patient is unavailable is termed ‘non-voluntary euthanasia’. Euthanasia conducted against the will of the patient is termed ‘involuntary euthanasia’.
According to the methods and procedure of performing euthanasia, it has been classified into active and passive euthanasia. ‘Active euthanasia’ entails the administration of lethal substances to kill. ‘Passive euthanasia’ entails
withholding of common treatments, such as antibiotics, necessary for the continuance of life.
Debate for or against euthanasia generally revolves around involuntary and active euthanasia, as if there is an agreement over passive and voluntary euthanasia which is not the case. Truth is that despite these classifications either
on the basis of consent or procedures the basic identity of the euthanasia i.e. it’s being either a callous murder or a timid suicide does not change in any circumstance. The example can be cited here of illicit sex. Sex has been classified as with
consent or without. Premarital, extramarital sex with consent is justified as a matter of choice and pleasure, while forceful sexual assault is considered wrong; same is their argument for euthanasia. As far as Islam is concerned it
allows only for marital sex in the first instance, and natural death in another. To say a bit lightly it can be argued that in Islam besides marriage only one death is justified i.e. natural death.
Euthanasia is one of the most contentious issues in the contemporary bioethics. Terri Schiavo’s case1 in 2005 had given the euthanasia debate international attention.
Euthanasia – the so-called mercy-killing – is legal in a number of countries like Switzerland, Belgium, Luxembourg and Netherlands; it is also legal in US states of Washington and Oregon. Passive euthanasia has been legalised throughout
US.
India on 7th March with the Supreme Court’s judgement allowing ‘passive’ euthanasia under ‘exceptional circumstances’joined these handful of ‘developed’ countries which have legalised mercy-killing in some form or the other. Aruna Shanbaug’s case is the focal point of the debate over euthanasia in India. She was working as a nurse at
Mumbai’s KEM Hospital when on the night of November 27, 1973, Sohanlal Bhartha Walmiki, a ward boy at the hospital,attacked and sodomised her in the hospital basement. During the attack she was strangled with a chain, and the deprivation of oxygen has left her in a vegetative state ever since. The attack left her cortically blind that means she can
see, but her brain does not register the sight. The convicted ward boy was let off after seven years of imprisonment. She has been treated at KEM since the incident and is kept alive by a feeding tube.
Pinki Virani has appealed for a ‘good death’ for Aruna. According to her Aruna has been ‘sentenced to life’2. She says,“Aruna Shanbaug. Sodomised. Strangled with a dog-chain while being brutalised. Extensive brain stem injury, partially
brain-dead, cortically blind. Cannot speak. Or walk. No control over bodily movements. Administered mashed food,swallows automatically, upchucks equally. Teeth loosening and falling—one by one—on her bed. In pain. Shrieking.
Howling. Weeping. Laughing manically. After the initial days, no medicines prescribed by the doctors, so none given”. In her article, as she is an award winning writer, she continues arguing eloquently that Aruna has been abandoned by
friends, abandoned by relatives, abandoned by doctors, abandoned by law and abandoned by God as well. In a much Bollywood-style God-punching rhetoric she justifies her stand vis-à-vis Aruna’s euthanasia as a choice for being morally
accountable to her and says, “no matter the consequences in the court of God”.Here like shrewdest of advocates – though she is not one – she is mixing up several things to justify what she assumes
to be ‘death with dignity’ for Aruna. Aruna has been provided with proper medical care & treatment or not; is an issue distinct from her euthanasia debate. No one disputes that proper care & treatment even at the expense of government
should be provided to her. Likewise people who are against Aruna’s euthanasia futilely argue that, Aruna is not in coma.Former Dean, KEM Hospital Dr Pragna Pai says, “I used to go and talk to her and when you tell some story, she would start
laughing or smiling or when you start singing some prayers or shlokhas, she would look very quiet and peaceful, as if she is also joining the prayers”3. No one disputes that if Aruna is conscious or she is not in a vegetative state she should be
allowed to live. Debate must also not concentrate on trivialities like the procedure laid down by the court for euthanasia for e.g. clearance of a medical board seconded by state government and high court etc.
The dispute is on euthanasia and one should stick to it if the matter has to be dealt academically and rationally,without any deviation from the core issue.
More comical, ridiculous, ludicrous and preposterous was the stand of the Indian government. In fact I feel that all the adjectives fail (even cumulatively) to convey the absurdity of the governmental stance. It did appeal in the court
against the euthanasia but cited the ‘argument’ that India is still a “backward and emotional country”4 and so euthanasia should not be allowed. This appeal on such farcical grounds was duly rejected by the court. It was like arguing that ‘I am
hungry, please allow me to have food, as I want to gather strength to loot the bank’. No doubt such right claims have to be rejected due to their wrong premises. Was government sincere in its opposition of euthanasia? This is a question that
better not to be tackled here.Any new notion irrespective of its being good or bad cannot be popularised from above through rulings and legislations and euthanasia is not an exception. Levelling of public opinion and mass consciousness is vital. This task is performed
through literature, movies, festivals etc. When popular consciousness is not ripe and rulings like Shah Bano case are delivered than mass uproar follow suit. And thus movements like LGBT are exploiting dramas, street plays, novels and
other cultural tools to pollute the common psyche. Same is true for the euthanasia movement. Pinki Virani’s ‘non-fiction novel’5 Aruna’s Story: The true account of a rape and its aftermath and the movie Guzaarish (2010) by Sanjay Leela Bhansali can be cited as examples of cultural tools to
acquaint the mass consciousness with euthanasia. Filmfare gave the movie a four star rating stating, “In a film where life itself is the villain everything is larger than life, no surprise there. The house is grand, the characters even more so, the
laughter is magnificent, the pain operatic and the treatment of all of the above is colossal in a deafening, attention seeking way that leaves no room for subtext or imagination6”.
Pain and suffering of the survivor is always used as integuments to hide the materialistic aspect of euthanasia. The story of the film is based in Goa, where one of the most accomplished magicians of the time, Ethan Mascarenhas lived.
Ethan got severely injured when his former best friend Yaseer Siddiqui, (also a magician) betrays him by corrupting one of his dangerous magic tricks, causing him to become quadriplegic. With this spinal injury he lives as lively and vivacious as possible for fourteen years. As a Radio Jockey of an FM Station Radio Zindagi, he spreads laughter through his irresistible wit and humour. Movie reaches its climax when on 14th anniversary of his accident Ethan realises that he is deceiving no one but himself. He is not, he will not and in fact he cannot be happy. He then appeals in court for mercykilling amidst high drama. Moral of the story: a quadriplegic or any severely ill person cannot truly be happy.
A sad life is not worth living. And so a sad person should have the right to end his sad life – Q.E.D. Yes! Life can be sad, miserable and pathetic with or even without any serious illness or injury. Do all the ‘sad’ people enjoy the ‘natural right’ to suicide is a question that I leave upon ardent advocates of euthanasia to answer. Other arguments against euthanasia and stance of Islam are dealt in detail by Dr. Majid Katme in a subsequent article.
Here I would just compare the on-screen character of Ethan with a real life character – Sheikh Ahmed Yaseen. Sheikh Ahmed Yaseen was paralyzed in his youth (about 20 yrs of age) as a result of an accident while exercising on
the beaches of Gaza. Sheikh Yaseen, other than his complete paralysis, suffered a number of other disabilities and diseases including loss of eyesight in his right eye due to Israeli blows during interrogation in addition to weakness in
his left eye. He also suffered from chronic inflammation in his ear, lung infection and other diseases in his abdomen. He was jailed several times and brutally tortured by Israeli forces for a cumulative period of around a decade. He lived for
66 years as a preacher & orator in mosques, as a campaigner for political awakening, as a leader of Islamic resistance movement (Hamas) against the most repressive of the colonial forces backed by superpowers of the world. In short a
person, who couldn’t move on his own, moved a whole nation. Believe me, he didn’t file any petition to be mercy-killed,but yes he met not ‘good’ but ‘best death’ possible. He was ‘mercy-killed’ by Israel not through some lethal injections but
through missiles fired from helicopters.
What’s the difference between Ethan and Sheikh Ahmed Yaseen besides earlier being ‘filmy’ and the later being real? The difference is of iman, of Islam.
Advocates of euthanasia need not read & preach books like Final Exit: The Practicalities of Self-Deliverance and Assisted Suicide for the Dying or The Peaceful Pill Handbook7, to learn how to escape life, how to succumb to illness or injuries; in
short how to die. They should read & preach instead, what Sheikh Ahmed Yaseen read & preached throughout his life, the book called Quran, to learn how to deal with problems, how to combat with miseries, how to cope up with despair; in
short how to live. Surely the people, who learn the art of living that Quran teaches, would cease to advocate euthanasia.



0 Comments