SIO has submitted its concerns and recommendations on the proposed UGC draft regulations, which dilute subject expertise, promote privatization, contractualize faculty positions, and erode academic autonomy. These changes threaten the integrity of publicly funded higher education institutions, making them vulnerable to corporate interests and political intervention. To safeguard academic excellence, transparency, and equitable opportunities, we urge the UGC to reconsider these provisions and uphold the foundational values of higher education in India.
Proposed Amendments to the UGC Draft Regulations 2025
1. Strengthening Subject-Specific Expertise
• Ensure that faculty recruitment mandates both a postgraduate (PG) degree and a PhD in the relevant discipline to maintain academic rigor and expertise.
• Remodify Clauses 3.2 and 3.3, which allow faculty appointments in disciplines where candidates have not pursued UG or PG studies, as this weakens subject-specific competency based on only NET.
• Professional degrees such as MBBS, veterinary science, and allied sciences should be excluded from these guidelines, as they already undergo rigorous interdisciplinary training.
For these disciplines, a PG degree and higher qualifications should be mandated for furtherresearch and teaching expertise.
2. Ensuring Fair and Transparent Recruitment Processes
• Remove the arbitrary weightage given to extra-curricular activities in appointments and promotions to maintain a focus on academic credentials and teaching experience.
• Modify Clause 3.11 to ensure that the credibility of peer-reviewed publications is verified through independent academic bodies rather than left to the discretion of selection committees, thereby preventing favoritism and nepotism.
• Recognize and assign explicit weightage to past teaching experience in recruitment and promotions to prevent a preference for fresh candidates who lack pedagogical exposure.
3. Preventing Corporate-Driven Agendas in Academia
• Reconsider the specific weightage assigned to research and teaching labs, sponsored research, and startup funding (Clauses 2, 3, and 9 of Clause 3.8), as these create unfair conditions for scholars from underfunded institutions and favor private-sector dependency.
Ensure that the development of research labs is supported through government funding rather than compelling faculty to rely on private sponsorships that may dictate research agendas for corporate benefit rather than public interest
• Resist the imposition of a corporate-driven research model that threatens the autonomy of public-funded universities and may result in an unjustified shift away from societal needs.
4. Protecting Academic Freedom and Diversity of Thought
• Reconsider the overemphasis on the Indian Knowledge System (Clause 5 of 3.8) to prevent insularity in academic research and ensure continued engagement with global and critical perspectives.
• Preserve academic freedom by allowing faculty the agency to engage with diverse intellectual traditions and frameworks without restrictive impositions.

5. Opposing the Contractualization of Faculty Positions
• Reinstate the 10% cap on contractual faculty appointments, which was present in the 2018 UGC Regulations but has been removed in the new draft.
• Recognize that the removal of this cap will lead to the mass contractualization of teaching posts, causing employment instability, the deterioration of service conditions, and an overall weakening of the quality of teaching-learning processes in HEIs.
• Address the threats posed by increased teacher-student ratios, UGCF’s multiple entry-exit model, and increased reliance on online courses (MOOCs, cluster colleges, etc.), all of which contribute to faculty downsizing and erode the need for permanent teaching positions.
6. Preventing the Corporate Takeover of Higher Education Governance
Remove Clause 9.0 on Professor of Practice (PoP), which allows the hiring of up to 10% of professionals from industry and non-academic professions. This provision:
1. Undermines the role of full-time faculty by prioritizing industry professionals with no pedagogical experience.
2. Promotes further corporatization of HEIs by embedding private interests inpublic-funded institutions.
3. Creates a new category of faculty members who may not be easily organized into trade unions and may be more vulnerable to administrative and political pressures.
7. Protecting the Public Character of Universities
• Modify Clause 10.1 on the appointment of Vice Chancellors, which allows bureaucrats, corporate leaders, and industry professionals to be appointed as Vice Chancellors.
• Reinstate the requirement that Vice chancellors must have an academic background, ensuring they possess the necessary experience to lead universities.
Remove the Clause 10.1 (iii), (iv), and (vi) on the constitution of the Search-cum Selection Committee, which undermines federalism and state autonomy by allowing greater central and political intervention in state universities.
• Prevent the politicization of university administration by maintaining an independent and transparent selection process for Vice Chancellors, free from undue government and corporate influence.
8. Ensuring Equitable Development of Higher Education
• Recognize the disparity in infrastructure, funding, and academic hierarchy across institutions and introduce provisions that ensure equitable access to research grants and development funding, especially for marginalized institutions.
• Ensure state-supported funding mechanisms to assist universities in developing research labs and faculty projects without forcing reliance on private investors.
The proposed UGC draft regulations dilute subject expertise, promote privatization, contractualize faculty positions, and erode academic autonomy. These changes threaten the integrity of publicly funded higher education institutions, making them vulnerable to corporate interests and political intervention. To safeguard academic excellence, transparency, and equitable opportunities, we urge the UGC to reconsider these provisions and uphold the foundational values of higher education in India.



0 Comments